News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Finance 
 Battle of bowsers, boozers: Nelson's budget reply 

Battle of bowsers, boozers: Nelson's budget reply

16/05/2008 7:18:00 AM
Opposition Leader Brendan Nelson has sought to revive his ailing leadership with pledges to cut petrol excise and block a 70pc tax hike on pre-mixed alcoholic drinks.

In a crucial performance watched intently by his back bench last night, Dr Nelson also vowed in his budget reply speech to stop an exodus from health insurance by blocking Labor's plan to cut a tax slug on higher earners without private cover.

Pitching himself as a friend of the battlers, Dr Nelson charged that Labor had failed the people it promised to help at the last election in "an underwhelming budget … of lost opportunity".

"This is an old-fashioned high-taxing, high-spending Labor budget that seeks to punish those it does not like and discourage aspiration," he said.

The pitch came at the end of a day dominated by a parliamentary fight over the alcopops tax hike, with Coalition health spokesman Joe Hockey waving around small bottles of sparkling wine and a rum-based mixed drink during question time to accuse the Government of double standards, because the wine had twice the alcohol content but attracted half the tax rate.

Health Minster Nicola Roxon insisted the move on alcopops was a health measure, not a tax grab, because Treasury modelling predicted it would cut consumption by up to 55 million bottles a year by 2011.

Dr Nelson charged that the plan would merely hit "responsible Australians who happen to enjoy a pre-mixed Bundy and coke or scotch and dry" and vowed to use the Coalition majority in the Senate to oppose the excise bill.

Coalition senators yesterday referred the issue to an inquiry, delaying a vote until June 24.

Dr Nelson also pledged to convene a summit to bring together experts to devise a strategy to tackle binge drinking.

Despite the Coalition's rejection of calls for a petrol tax cut when it was in government, Dr Nelson last night proposed a "responsible and fair" cut of five cents a litre, to cost $1.8 billion a year.

He pilloried Labor's appointment of a petrol commissioner, saying: "Watching petrol prices does not bring them down."

On private health insurance, Dr Nelson said that lifting the threshold for the Medicare tax surcharge would damage the whole system.

"Health insurance premiums will increase with measures that will see … half a million mainly young people drop out — leaving families, pensioners and retirees to face higher premiums," he said.

In other pledges, he proposed a capital gains tax break for people who sell a small business they have owned for five years to fund retirement.

He also committed the Coalition to restore the Investing in Our Schools program and to force trainee teachers to learn to teach reading with phonics.

He also vowed to block Labor's plan to expand the income test for the seniors health card to include super salary sacrifice contributions.

The Treasury advice on alcopops says it is difficult to predict the impact of the tax increase.

But while it admits the hike could result in people simply drinking more of other products, it assumes there will be no impact on overall alcohol consumption.

Mr Hockey said that the Treasury advice showed there was a 50-50 chance that people would go to alternative drinks with more alcohol.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd hit back, saying it was remarkable that Dr Nelson had initially supported the alcopops tax for a week after it was announced.

He said the Liberal Party had lost its way on social policy issues such as binge drinking.

Family First senator Steve Fielding, who has campaigned for a 10-cent petrol excise cut since 2005, last night applauded the Coalition plan.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Please stop the reds from removing all the fun in this life.

Nanny, give me back my booze.

Posted by THE FARMER on 16/05/2008 4:32:33 PM
Unbelievable! The Alchohol industry (together with developers) controls the NSW state government, & now it's contoling the Federal Opposition.

We have a major social problem with teenage binge drinking & Nelson caves in (he's desperate).

The argument that kids will now mix their own drinks, & this is a tax grab, is simply paraphrasing the alchohol industry's statements (ney, lest it affect the profit).

Do you really, for e.g., believe that pubs will let kids bring their own mixed drinks onto the premises?

I don't think so (ney, lest it affect the profit).

Posted by razor on 19/05/2008 1:58:56 PM
Editor's note: I hate to disagree, but speaking from my experience many years ago as a university student (before alcopops even existed), money was the key driver in what - not how much - students drank. How much students drank was always excessive - binge drinking was a problem then as it is now. But if they were strapped for cash, students would happily buy cheap cask wine and hold a party at home, rather than pay for more expensive drinks at the pubs. From that experience, I think the Opposition's criticisms of the alcopop tax are legitimate.
Posted by Michael Thomson on 19/05/2008 3:25:19 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Opposition Leader Brendan Nelson discusses tactics with Joe Hockey.
Opposition Leader Brendan Nelson discusses tactics with Joe Hockey.

Q: Do you support the Federal Government's initiatives in re-opening the live export trade with Egypt?

Yes
(24.9%)

No
(75.1%)

Total Votes: 630
Poll Date: 11/05/2008

26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
S&L Subscriptions
 
S&L Advertising
 
Rural Bookshop
 
Horse Deals Australia
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...