News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Finance 
 Rural Australia 'sacrificed' by $23.7m water buyback 

Rural Australia 'sacrificed' by $23.7m water buyback

11 Sep, 2008 07:23 PM
The purchase of Toorale Station in the Bourke Shire will do nothing to improve the current drought induced crisis in the Murray Darling Basin, the federal Shadow Minister for Water Security, John Cobb says.

Mr Cobb said, "We cannot support such ad hoc buybacks - until we have seen the promised socio-economic impact studies on the effect of buying water from these communities and until the Commonwealth and State Governments can clearly define what their environmental objectives are and exactly what the sustainable yields in the valleys are.

“The Bourke,NSW, community has been gutted by the news that one of the nation's major food producing properties, Toorale Station will be turned into a National Park," he said today.

“With over 100 hundred jobs directly lost as a result of the purchase of Toorale Station, coupled with the on-going drought and the 400 jobs lost from the mines in neighbouring Cobar, the economy of far western NSW has taken a massive hit under the Rudd Government’s policies.

Mr Cobb says the Rudd Government has abolished the Coalition’s $1.5 billion structural adjustment package, which is part of the $10bn National Plan for Water Security.

“Country communities are extremely concerned they are being sacrificed to the environmental green shoe brigade by the Rudd Government, which has shown it could not care less about the future of rural communities.

“At the very least, all fixed charges such as council rates, Rural Land Protection Board rates and water charges should continue to be paid by the State and Federal Governments.

“The decision to buy Toorale Station will be felt by all Australians.

"And the Rudd Government has already announced it will be buying up huge tracks of prime agricultural land in Queensland to obtain the water entitlements.

"This, in turn, will further drive up the price of basic food items.

“We all know the NSW Government has turned NSW into an economic basket case and already questions are being asked about how they will manage Toorale Station.

“Leaks from the NSW National Parkes and Wildlife Service suggest that the service has been told to draw up a two-year management plan for Toorale Station.

"But they have been told there will be no extra funding for the new National Park.

“Minister Wong needs to explain what will be happening with the wheat crop on Toorale Station.

" It would be a national disgrace, given global food shortages, if this crop was not harvested."

Mr Cobb said the water stored at Toorale will be need to released back into the river immediately as summer is approaching and the stored water will begin to rapidly evaporate.

“I hold grave concerns the water stored at Toorale Station will be release at the height of summer - and unless there are major rains in the short term to run into the Darling River, then not one drop of Toorale’s water will reach the Menindee Lakes.

“It is now obvious that under the Rudd Government’s current water policies when the drought finally breaks, Murray Darling Basin communities will go from a climatic drought straight in to a Rudd-made drought,” he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
WELL MR COBB THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE WHO MIGHT DISAGREE WITH YOU...
Posted by CHRIS, 11/09/2008 4:57:54 PM
It's like an episode of the "The Hollowmen". Will the Government now have the courage to actually do something smart for the environment and buy land back from graziers in our iconic wetlands? Who has the best track record in managing natural resources productively? Farmers or government departments? Perhaps irrigators should be contracted to manage environmental water and wetlands for outcomes?
Posted by Bruce, 11/09/2008 9:13:47 PM
Well now the National parks have bought up Toorale Station I would love the burr chipping contract......it would last a lifetime!
Posted by dummyone, 11/09/2008 9:23:15 PM
Wanna bet that the new Toorale National Park will be over run by weeds and feral animals within five years. During drought years such as we have been having, this costly purchase will not contribute positively, one iota to the problems of water flow in the Darling.

I just wonder. I have a piece of degraded land that I have planted to trees and is now a productive forestry plantation. Maybe I could get a million or two from the gubment man for the 11 acres of it? For that price, they can have the carbon credits as I won't get them anyway because I want to harvest the timber.

Posted by Trugger, 11/09/2008 10:20:58 PM
I think that while the govenrment has the right idea about putting water back into our river systems they are really going the wrong way about it. They seem to have no understanding of the socio-economic effects this purchase will have on the local community, no local jobs increases unemployment, are the governments going to offer the same funding to the region to reskill these workers? The wheat crop will need to be managed and harvested.... Has this been considered? What is the plan for Toorale after two years? Most places plan for at least 5 at a time with an ongoing plan and aims and objectives in place. Are we going to lose a productive enterprise to the bureaucratic bungling Australia has become used to? What is going to happen to the infrastructure in place on Toorale, is it going to sit threre for the next 100 years as a reminder of what happens to our productive pastoral land when the govenrment decides it feels a need to take over and has more money than sense? The water held on Toorale should have some sort of water plan, is this available for public viewing? In my mind there are too many unanswered questions. Will this end up like Wilandra Lakes?
Posted by Kylie, 12/09/2008 9:57:42 AM
In response to "Posted by CHRIS on 11/09/2008 3:57:54 PM". Having worked all over rural Australia on both family owned and corporate owned properties, and in small towns like Katherine NT and Mungindi NSW; guess what?! I don't disagree with John Cobb.
Posted by mbh, 12/09/2008 10:25:14 AM
I agree with John Cobb on this one. How well has the govt thought this out? What will be the ongoing effects of taking out of production these valuable businesses?
Posted by Matt, 12/09/2008 1:11:14 PM
What has Cobb ever achieved for the Darling except be one of those involved in the over allocation of water and part of the cause of our present problems? Sitting on your hands and flapping your jaw will do little to alleviate the problem. The Toorale buy could be the first small step man.
Posted by Richard Woolley, 12/09/2008 1:35:35 PM
For those who wish to blame the condition of the Murray/Lower Lakes on over-allocations and mismanagement, have a read of the Murray Darling Basin Commission's Drought Update, September 15, 2008.

It clearly states: "A persistent rainfall deficiency during the past 7 years, particularly in the alpine areas, has been the main cause for the record low inflows to the Murray system."

Why do we always like to blame human actions rather than nature?

Posted by Dick, 17/09/2008 9:16:29 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Federal Shadow Minister for Water Security, John Cobb.
Federal Shadow Minister for Water Security, John Cobb.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: If a Federal election was held next weekend, for which party would you vote?

Labor
(12.2%)

Liberal
(38.2%)

Nationals
(27.5%)

Greens
(8.6%)

Family First
(1.7%)

Independent
(7.3%)

Undecided/Other
(4.5%)

Total Votes: 1040
Poll Date: 07 September, 2008

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...