News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Govt has got it wong on CDMA shutdown says Windsor 

Govt has got it wong on CDMA shutdown says Windsor

16/04/2008 1:00:00 PM
Tony Windsor, the Independent Member for New England, has criticised the Federal Government's decision to shut the CDMA mobile phone network on April 28.

Mr Windsor says Stepehen Conroy, the Minister for Broadband, Communication and the Digital Economy, has pulled the wrong rein.

Mr Windsor says he passed on interim results of a survey of people in his electorate in North West NSW to Senator Conroy prior to the Minister's announcement which he claims clearly showed that equivalence of service with Next G has not been achieved and therefore Telstra should not be allowed to shut the CDMA network.

"I am disappointed that Minister Conroy is going to allow Telstra to shut the CDMA network when feedback from people in the New England electorate is telling me and him that the NextG mobile phone service is not equivalent to the CDMA network.

"That was the undertaking freely given by Telstra when they announced the NextG network would be replacing the CDMA network and the evidence from people using the system indicates that this has not been achieved yet," Mr Windsor says.

He believes the Minister's decision now removes any real control over Telstra delivering equity of service to country people and blames the decision of the former Government to fully sell off Telstra for the current situation.

"The Government has now lost its political leverage over the fully privatised Telstra.

"Telstra is now only answerable to its shareholders and will be driven by profits and dividends back to its shareholders - not to deliver services to people in areas where it will actually cost them money to do so.

"The writing was on the wall when the previous Coalition Government used its numbers in the Senate to sell off Telstra aided by the National Farmers Federation under the guise that they had received guarantees from the Coalition Government that equity of access to phone and broadband for country people would be enshrined in the legislation.

"Well, nothing was enshrined in the legislation and we now have the NSW Farmers Association that was a party to the NFF decision to support the full sale of Telstra now complaining about the lack of mobile phone service to its members.

"You can't blame the cow for getting out when you open the gate for it," Mr Windsor says.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Sometimes I wonder whether Government should keep out of decisions like this. For those of us that have transferred to NextG (and nearly evereybody I know has) we are waiting to see if our reception improves once CDMA is turned off as Telstra has indicated.
Posted by Rob on 17/04/2008 10:58:49 AM
With my CDMA phone I could not get reception on my farm except for one spot where I stood on the top of a gate post and pointed in the right direction. When changing over to a Next G phone we borrowed several from a Telstra shop to try on the farm, most of which were useless. However when we then tried ZTE phone carrying the Telstra label and recommended by Telstra for rural use, we can get reception anywhere on the farm. Perhaps many people aren't using the right handpiece for the right situation.
Posted by Charlie on 17/04/2008 1:34:48 PM
Using the "wrong handset" is a smoke screen invented by Telstra as a ploy to divert attention away from the fact that NextG isn't as good as CDMA.

1. If the handsets are to blame, why did Telstra release them into the market?

2. Why has changing handsets not rectified the problem for people with reception issues?

Sen CONROY has now proven himself to be a spineless jellyfish and should hang his head in shame for misleading the Australian public and allowing CDMA to be switched off, when there is ample evidence at his disposal that NextG has failed to meet the equivalence of service requirement we were all promised, over vast areas of the continent.

This promise was made by Telstra themselves, the previous and current federal government, so there can be no excuse whatsoever for the catastrophy which is about to occur.

In an attempt to meet the benchmark criteria, Telstra has even stooped to reducing the performance of the CDMA network and NextG is still inadequate by comparison!!

The end of CDMA will herald a retrospective step in mobie phone communications, as well as consign countess country CDMA users to the receptionless world of NextG.

I am dumbfounded as to how this can happen in Australia, in the year 2008.

I feel abandoned and betrayed by this new Labor Government.

They were elected on a platform of protecting us from exactly what they are now permitting.

I encourage everyone affected to write to their local MP and Sen CONROY noting every one of their experienced NextG reception inadequecies.

Posted by CQ on 17/04/2008 9:53:38 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Q: Do you believe the Next G mobile phone network is equivalent or better than the CDMA network?

Yes
(20.6%)

No
(79.4%)

Total Votes: 199
Poll Date: 16/04/2008

26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
S&L Subscriptions
 
S&L Advertising
 
Rural Bookshop
 
Horse Deals Australia
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...