News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Scrap ETS and go for a carbon tax: Garnaut 

Scrap ETS and go for a carbon tax: Garnaut

26 Jan, 2010 06:45 AM
KEVIN RUDD'S former climate change adviser, Ross Garnaut, has urged the Government to put behind it the "fiasco" of Copenhagen and to forge ahead with a scheme to reduce greenhouse gases, even if that means turning its emissions trading scheme into a de facto carbon tax.

In a speech yesterday, Professor Garnaut said a binding international agreement to reduce greenhouse gases would never be reached at such open forums as the United Nations conference in Copenhagen last month.

''The important decisions will need to be made wisely by a group of major countries, drawing on detailed numerical work by experts representing heads of government,'' he said.

Just because Copenhagen was a fiasco did not mean climate change had disappeared as a problem, he said. And if Australia acted, it would be easier for countries such as the United States to move.

Professor Garnaut said Australia could lead the way by establishing a regional emissions trading scheme with like-minded neighbours.

He suggested a double dissolution election be held, then a scheme passed in which the price of carbon, rather than being floated according to market forces, was fixed indefinitely at about $20 a tonne, as the Greens suggested last week.

In effect this arrangement would act as a carbon tax. It would still reduce emissions and stay in place until a satisfactory international agreement emerged.

Parliament resumes next Tuesday and the Government will reintroduce legislation for the ETS complete with the industry-friendly amendments that Malcolm Turnbull and Ian Macfarlane negotiated last year.

The failure of the Copenhagen talks and the trenchant resistance of the Opposition Leader, Tony Abbott, to any market-based mechanism have made the ETS a vexed issue for the Government.

Before Parliament resumes, Mr Abbott will release a policy that will claim to be able to reduce emissions by planting trees, better soil management and energy-efficiency measures.

The former Opposition leader, Mr Turnbull, has pledged to cross the floor to support the amended ETS.

In his Australia Day message in his seat of Wentworth yesterday, he took a swipe at Mr Abbott, saying climate change was ''an issue that cries out for strong, far-sighted leadership both at home and internationally''.

Mr Turnbull also teased that he may try again for the leadership. ''Part of our special Australian identity, too, is a spirit of enterprise and resilience, a willingness to get in and have a go, and if that doesn't work out, dust yourself off and have another go.''

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size



RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Here we go again, Garnaut the economist who is paid by Labor trying to get another 5 minutes of air time. "if Australia acted, it would be easier for countries such as the United States to move". What crap, do these people really think that the Australian population (other than the true believers) is so gullible to believe such a statement. Turnbull should go and have a cold shower and not continue to act like a spoiled brat.
Posted by jerangle, 26/01/2010 8:28:03 AM, on The Land
Carbon is a hoax, scrap all taxes
Posted by jim, 26/01/2010 8:32:06 AM, on The Land
Of course Malcolm would cross the floor, he’s a Labor licker. No one can get near the ETS because of the smell of rotting corpse so the lovelies in politics want to find another pretext to screw average mums and dads.
Posted by Turnbul faction of the Labor party, 26/01/2010 9:01:36 AM, on The Land
What deranged thinking! How do we get the message through - taxes are negative and punitive and do nothing directly to reduce Green House Gases. Fast growing crops and pastures are best. Trees come a distant second. It would be better to cut them down and make way for fast growing crops and pastures
Posted by daw, 26/01/2010 9:53:08 PM, on The Land
Ross Garnuat & Kevin Rudd, that's the mentality that we're expected to stoop to?
Posted by Atheistno1, 27/01/2010 6:07:25 AM, on The Land
Correct me if I am wrong.... but Rudd recently stated he will compensate low and middle income earners for any additional taxes or costs associated with carbon emissions. I fail to comprehend how this illogical mumbo jumbo will provide any deterrent to those being compensated and (as they represent approximately 85% of the Australian population) It will therefore achieve little overall to any meaningful reduction in carbon emissions but will provide a windfall to accountants and tax planners. Australian bureaucrats seem to specialise in creating this sort of crap. Peter Saunders
Posted by Peter, 27/01/2010 8:15:54 AM, on The Land
...and look who the article is written by, onya Phil. Is the reason for the rush to get all this through, under what ever name, because of certain rain events and the forecast for more??? It seems that this group of leaders and bureaucrats and a fair percentage of the media really is on the wong ruddy bus. How is it that something that is so important to saving the world can't stand on its own two feet and be called just one thing. Either the world is in dire straits or it is not, if it is then this lot are pathetic as they consistently show that they would struggle to organise and run a pumpkin scone competition.
Posted by katandra, 27/01/2010 8:17:03 AM, on Stock Journal
It is a real shame that the Liberal party still cannot bring itself to uphold truth and denounce fraud! As long as they try to appease the supporters of the CO2 scam by suggesting measures to reduce emissions they give implied support to that scam. I suggest they give 'truth' a go, bring on a double disallution, if indeed Rudd is game and let the people have a say in their destiny, rather than have us suffer the above trash.
Posted by 'Rob Roy', 27/01/2010 8:38:03 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Businesses will just cough up the extra $20 per tonne tax and then pass it onto consumers. There needs to be mandated targets set and big fines for non compliance - and they could probably use most of the existing environmental legislation and then we wouldn't need another explosion in the bureaucracy to administer any tax. Just a few more to monitor and fine the non compliers.
Posted by Maybalene, 27/01/2010 9:15:27 AM, on The Land
Is this Garnaut the bloke advising the Rudd government? And spouting such elitist crap? Talking of major countries making "wise" decisions and "experts representing heads of government" and the abandonment of open forums. We see here a glimpse of the motivation behind these people. Having been defeated at Copenhagen they seek to push their failed agenda by whatever other clandestine means they can. They are against open discussion and an involvement by the majority in the decision making process. They will attempt to have their way against the will of the people. Expect more of this sort of thing in the future, although most of it will go unreported, and down the track we will be asked to accept some situation to which we have had no input. Who is this Garnaut bloke anyway? What are his qualifications and background?
Posted by ozfirst, 27/01/2010 9:40:23 AM, on The Land
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Professor Ross Garnaut
Professor Ross Garnaut
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
POLL
Q: What is the biggest challenge currently facing Australian agriculture?

Animal activists
(9.6%)

Poor urban perceptions
(8.9%)

Red tape
(6.6%)

Low farmgate prices
(39.1%)

Carbon emissions policies
(10.6%)

Property rights
(15.6%)

Other
(9.5%)

Total Votes: 861
Poll Date: 24 January, 2010
BLOGS
20 January, 2010

Most popular articles

Ray White Rural MON0152
 
IRRIGATION CONFERENCE 2010
 
2010 Beef & Cattle Directory
 
S&L Subscriptions
 
Rural Bookshop
 
S&L Twitter
 
S&L Facebook
 
photo gallery


 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...