News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Spencer hunger strike drives wedge into Coalition 

Spencer hunger strike drives wedge into Coalition

05 Jan, 2010 06:57 AM
NSW farmer Peter Spencer hunger strike in protest against land-clearing laws has renewed tensions between Liberal and National parties.

Protesters cheered the Nationals senator Barnaby Joyce and heckled the Liberal senator Bill Heffernan yesterday as they gathered outside Parliament House in support of the farmer.

Mr Spencer, of Shannons Flat near Cooma, whose family said he had not eaten for 43 days, is protesting - on a platform 10 metres up a wind-monitoring tower on his property - against laws that prevent him from clearing vegetation on his land.

Mr Spencer's cause has drawn the climate-sceptics network together, mobilised via blogs, and has renewed tensions in the Coalition as it seeks to unite under Tony Abbott's leadership after a year of infighting.

Senator Heffernan, a former member of the Howard government, has criticised Mr Spencer's supporters for not doing more to end his hunger strike.

''I think it's barbaric that we're all sitting around here wondering how long the bloke is going to last … I think they, absolutely this afternoon, should go and get him, and take him to hospital,'' Senator Heffernan said.

He said the land-clearing regulations were flawed but not all land was suitable for farming.

''I'm used to being booed down,'' Senator Heffernan said after the rally. ''People sometimes don't like to hear what they need to hear.''

In contrast, Senator Joyce, who was elevated to Opposition finance spokesman in last month's reshuffle, was cheered by more than 200 demonstrators who waved placards and Eureka flags.

''The Australian people are starting to say we've had enough of being signed up to these agreements, where you get the kudos, or the happy clapping in Bali or some conference, but the bill goes home to the working families, the bill goes home to the family farm,'' Senator Joyce said.

A spokesman for the Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, said the Government had urged Mr Spencer to seek medical attention.

Last month Mike Kelly, the Labor MP for local electorate, Eden-Monaro, travelled to Mr Spencer's farm to meet him on behalf of Mr Rudd, but Mr Spencer apparently refused to see him.

The spokesman said the state land-clearing legislation was introduced more than 10 years ago, and no action taken by the Federal Government in relation to climate change had altered the way that farmers could use their land.

''The Government believes this matter should be settled through the legal system,'' the spokesman said.

The Climate Sceptics Party had been promoting Mr Spencer's cause, its president, Leon Ashby, told the Sydney Morning Herald.

Yesterday's event was more successful than a rally on the issue, which had been planned for last week outside Kirribilli House. It was cancelled after only a handful of people promised to attend.

A former ABC radio science presenter, Joanne Nova, also known as Joanne Codling, is also trying to mobilise support for Mr Spencer. She runs a Perth-based climate sceptics website.

Ms Nova and her partner, David Evans, also a prominent climate sceptic, attended the United Nations Bali climate change conference with the support of The Heartland Institute, a US research institute that is campaigning against efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and against research that links passive smoking to cancer.

Mr Spencer's daughter Sarah said her father had lost a lot of weight and was increasingly weak but was mentally healthy.

''We've all vowed that until he's not of sound mind, it's his choice whether he stays up there or comes down.''

The president of the NSW branch of the Australian Medical Association, Brian Morton, said Mr Spencer's long-term health could be seriously affected by the hunger strike.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Interesting to note reference to Heartland Institute that is supporting the secptics is funded by ExxonMobil and Phillip Morris and push to discredit climate change and the links of passive smoking to cancer.
Posted by Mike, 5/01/2010 7:51:59 AM
What a sorry state Australian politics is in! - A Prime Minister who is only interested in the welfare of economic refugees and a Liberal party totally out of touch with what is going on!
Posted by Tigerdicky, 5/01/2010 8:02:20 AM
Rural Australia has to start thinking laterally if we are to survive this change in climate. Otherwise we risk becoming totally extinct. Like the mining towns of times past, they had to change face to survive. Towns that didn't change faded into history. Lets get our heads out of the sand on this climate issue and show some true australian gumption.
Posted by Pete - Upper Murray, 5/01/2010 9:30:28 AM
Mike. It's interesting to note that the US government alone. Has spent $79 billion trying to prove a link between climate change and human activity. Yet has spent nothing looking for alternative causes of climate change. In spite of the $79 billion no real world proof of carbon dioxide driving climate change has been found. The only thing that $79 billion is found is that climate change's and no one is 100% sure of why, and what causes it.
Posted by Qlander, 5/01/2010 1:22:08 PM
Why is it that the government is able to compensate the coal industry for any negative effects of climate change, to the point of making the whole CPRS scheme pointless, but refuses to even discuss compensation for those farmers effected by tree clearing bans that have been the reaqson we are even partly credable in regards to Kyoto.
Posted by linden, 5/01/2010 1:25:47 PM
Mike Number 1: Interesting to note that the Sydney Morning Herald is so biased against farmers that they bother to try to smear me (I've just written a few blog posts on the man ferrgoodnesssake) in a short article supposedly about a man starving himself to protest at a gross constitutional failure. Where's the balance? BTW: I wrote the "Climate Money" paper that Qlander Quotes, exposing the $79 billion in funds paid to the Climate Industry in the US. We all need to stand up for farmers, because the mainstream media sure isn't.
Posted by JoNova, 6/01/2010 4:53:00 AM
Bill Heffernan's contribution to Monday night's ABCTV news was disgusting, an outstanding example of the bleepwitted apologist Liberal party thinking that has done so much damage to rural Australia over the last 25 years, and which was also National party policy too until Barnaby Joyce came along. The issue here is not whether Peter Spencer's land is, in Bill Heffernan's opinion, suitable for clearing. It is the expropriation of property rights without compensation. On TV news, before the Australian populace, Bill Heffernan supported the tree huggers and Marxists who want to dispossess Australia's landowners.
Posted by Ted O'Brien, 6/01/2010 7:19:34 AM
Bill has got to follow Turnbull and his best mate Johnny Howard out the door and take Tuckey with him. No more damage has been done to Australian farmers than at the hands of these treacherous Politicians. What they are responsible for in helping destroy the export wheat market sending all profit to the big world grain trade out of the hands of those who earnt it the growers is a act of treason. Heffernan made a big noise when fertiliser prices went through the roof as it was hurting his mate the largest grower in Australia. As having a Single desk stopped his mate from exporting his own Wheat in bulk. Bill does not support the majority but if you have ajistment for his cattle he might represent you?
Posted by Mark, 6/01/2010 8:08:01 AM
One Australian farmer is threatening to die for a cause, which deeply affects us all, and only a couple of politicians show any concern. The Prime Minister watches the cricket, and hosts a BBQ, he would rather speak to President Magabe about an ETS. Even NSW Farmers Association can only manage a tired press release. Good job they are actually supporting Peter Spencer, otherwise they might be arguing the merits of his campaign too. Peter is an Australian farmer. How apathetic can we all be?
Posted by Angusg, 6/01/2010 8:28:58 AM
And how many trees does Heffernan own? Do they have names? The days when the bush will vote for a Liberal in a hat are over. The relief shown by urban liberals by the ousting of Turnbull makes it clear that there is no "wedge" between the majority of conservative voters. The only wedge was the one formed by Vichy Liberals like Heffernan who sought to disenfranchise the silent majority. He must go.
Posted by Ian Mott, 6/01/2010 11:13:27 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Speaking out ... the leader of the National Party, Barnaby Joyce, addresses farmers who marched on Parliament House in support of hunger-striker Peter Spencer. Photo: Glen McCurtayne
Speaking out ... the leader of the National Party, Barnaby Joyce, addresses farmers who marched on Parliament House in support of hunger-striker Peter Spencer. Photo: Glen McCurtayne
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
POLL
Q: Do you believe your farm business will turn a profit in 2010?

Definitely
(10.4%)

Probably
(16.2%)

Maybe
(17.8%)

Break even
(15.2%)

Probably make a loss
(40.4%)

Total Votes: 512
Poll Date: 04 January, 2010

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...