News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Turnbull burnt by revolt on climate 

Turnbull burnt by revolt on climate

20 Nov, 2009 06:29 AM
MORE than half the Coalition's 37 senators have formally declared their opposition to Malcolm Turnbull's desire to cut a deal with Labor on the emissions trading scheme, setting up a showdown next week that many fear could tear the Opposition apart.

As the Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, linked the heatwave savaging southern Australia to global warming, the Coalition senators split into two camps - those backing Mr Turnbull and those backing the Opposition Senate leader and climate change sceptic, Nick Minchin.

In the most open show of defiance to date, 12 Liberals and all five Nationals sat in solidarity behind Senator Minchin as he slammed the emissions trading scheme and Mr Rudd's desire to pass it before the Copenhagen conference next month.

"Mr Rudd is prepared to sacrifice Australia's national interest on the altar of his vanity," Senator Minchin said.

The senator, who contends man-made climate change is a global left-wing conspiracy, said it was "a disgrace" to describe carbon dioxide as pollution.

"The Senate overwhelmingly rejected this abomination in August. It should do so again."

Apart from the show of force by the 17 senators - including the deputy Senate leader, Eric Abetz, who sat behind Senator Minchin, three others in the group were unable to attend.

That makes 21 out of 37 hostile to Mr Turnbull's acceptance that there should be a deal with Labor. In the corridors afterwards, Senator Minchin's supporters lauded the success of their display. "We were tightly packed behind him; it was a show of solidarity," said one.

While Mr Turnbull and his chief negotiator, Ian Macfarlane, are optimistic a deal will be struck with the Government and approved by a majority of Liberals, there are fears about the consequences of risking a large split.

Mr Turnbull's followers were speculating that should he prevail, Senator Minchin would have to leave the frontbench and should consider resigning altogether. Rebels believed Mr Turnbull's leadership would be untenable if he failed.

"This will leave a lingering bitterness in the party that will hang around for years," said one senior Liberal. Said another veteran: "There's more tension in the party than I have known in more than 15 years here."

Tony Abbott, who once advocated passing the bill, is now arguing internally that it should be opposed for the sake of party unity.

Senator Minchin's followers were claiming Mr Turnbull's "henchmen" were ringing young rebel senators and MPs and warning them they would be jeopardising their futures.

Mr Rudd demanded Mr Turnbull guarantee there be a vote before Parliament rises for the year next Thursday. As the nation sweltered in a spring heatwave, the Prime Minister lashed the Coalition's climate change deniers.

"It is as if we are back into the trial of Galileo or something and they are simply arguing somehow that science is a fiction and that they alone, in their own prejudiced view, occupy fact," he said.

"No wonder the Leader of the Opposition has such a hard time. If you have to put up with that mate, I have sympathy for you, I really do."

The Finance Minister, Lindsay Tanner, also ridiculed Senator Minchin and his followers.

"Senator Minchin is incubating a kind of rural militia from backwoods Montana in the Senate," he said.

Mr Macfarlane told a business function on Wednesday night that the call to wait until after Copenhagen was irrelevant because Mr Rudd was setting the timetable. He said the Government had a mandate to introduce an emissions trading scheme. "I'm negotiating on the basis that by the time the Senate rises at the end of next week he will have what he is demanding but it will be on our terms."

The Government needs seven Senate votes and there are more than enough Liberal senators who will support a scheme if the party accepts the Government's offer.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Elect Wilson Tuckey now!
Posted by tigerdicky, 20/11/2009 8:34:45 AM
Courage is contagious!!
Posted by Qlander, 20/11/2009 8:49:21 AM
Rudd will destroy the country if allowed to get away with this insane bill. What has happened to common sense? This man is the most dangerous lunatic that has ever been in power in Australia. He knows very well that his insane co2 theary is BS and has sold out to the UN world Govt gangsters.
Posted by hey loc, 20/11/2009 9:09:32 AM
Barnaby Joyce,Wilson Tuckey, Corey Bernardi and of course Nick Minchin have the future of Australia in their hands and rightly so.

Any of them would make good leaders. Nick Minchin should be knighted for his work against KRudd and his HOAX.

Posted by Paul, 20/11/2009 10:42:32 AM
Well done Libs. Turnbull is just a policyless sheep who follows Rudd to try and win popularity.
Posted by shaun, 20/11/2009 11:30:43 AM
Well done, Libs. Turnbull is just a policy-less sheep who follows Rudd to try and win popularity.
Posted by shaun, 20/11/2009 11:31:34 AM
Malcom Turnbull stood up in front of 500 delegates at this year's NSW Farmers conference and declared that the Liberals would in no way shape or form be supporting an ETS.

To openley mislead hard working farmers representatives across NSW, and then, not even a week later, state they are prepared to negotiate a deal with the opposition stinks to high heaven.

Tunbull is nothing more than a vote chasing politician looking out for his own interests.

I personally take offence at being lied to in such a manner, especially by such a high profile supposed leader.

At least Barnaby has the guts and belief to remain honest to himself and the people who also beleive this is nothing more than a TAX grab. SHAME ON YOU, MR TURNBULL. Maybe Malcolm should put this motto on his desk The Truth is the easiest thing to remember !!

Posted by David Noakes, 20/11/2009 1:38:43 PM
Don't get too excited guys - Labor only need 7 votes!!!
Posted by Mike, 20/11/2009 3:31:19 PM
I hope none of the above commentators line up for government aid when the weather turns for the worst! If you can't see why doing something to help the environment now is a good thing, then you don't deserve to be on the land.
Posted by Annoyed Youth, 20/11/2009 3:35:08 PM
PS, I thought doing something that a majority of people wanted is called "democracy". Rudd campaigned clearly on Climate Change last election. He was voted in. Australia wants a CPRS/ETS. You naysayers are just going to have to accept it.
Posted by Annoyed Youth, 20/11/2009 3:37:28 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Liberal Senate Leader Nick Minchin.
Liberal Senate Leader Nick Minchin.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
18 November, 2009
POLL
Q: Do you believe your farm business can profit from an emissions trading scheme?

Yes
(20.3%)

No
(70.1%)

Undecided
(9.6%)

Total Votes: 606
Poll Date: 15 November, 2009
BLOGS
19 November, 2009

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC FW



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...