News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Turnbull's ETS nightmare: Libs in melt down 

Turnbull's ETS nightmare: Libs in melt down

26 Nov, 2009 09:58 PM
The Liberal Party is in turmoil tonight following the resignation of six frontbenchers, including Tony Abbott and Senator Nick Minchin, after they refused to back Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull's position on the controversial emissions trading scheme.

Liberal frontbenchers Sophie Mirabella, Senator Eric Abetz, Tony Smith and Stephen Parry have also quit their positions over the ETS, leaving Malcolm Turnbull's future as leader in doubt.

It follows yesterday's resignations by fellow front benchers, Mitch Fifield, Mathias Cormann and Brett Mason, also in protest against Turnbull's ETS stance.

But in a press conference tonight Mr Turnbull said that while he respected his colleagues' decision, the issue was now one of integrity and it would be irresponsible for the party to not take action on climate change.

He said the Liberal Party could not be seen as the "do nothings on climate change" and also had to be men and women of our word after making a deal with the Government over the ETS.

"I am the leader of the Liberal Party," Mr Turnbull told reporters at a media conference in Canberra.

"I was confirmed as such ... just 24 hours ago."

However, the rebellion may not effect the passage of the legislation, with Labor needing just seven Liberal votes in the Senate to secure passage of the ETS.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has sought to exploit the chaos within the Liberal Party by setting 3.45pm Friday as the deadline for the vote, saying he expected the agreement reached with the Opposition to be honoured.

Earlier, Mr Abbott told reporters it was not a leadership issue but a policy issue. "This is an argument about policy. It is not an argument about the leadership," he said.

He said that he and Senator Minchin had seen Mr Turnbull in his office after question time this afternoon to ask him to reconsider his policy on emissions trading and delay a vote on Labor’s emissions trading scheme until next year, after the Copenhagen summit.

They had proposed the matter be put to a Senate inquiry but Mr Turnbull had said he was not prepared to reconsider.

"I indicated to Malcolm at the end of the conversation that given his position I could no longer support the opposition’s policy and therefore could no longer be in the shadow cabinet," he said.

He had no option but "to take the honourable course".

"It was a very civil, rational and courteous conversation conducted in a spirit of mutual respect," said Mr Abbott.

He said in the light of the fact he could no longer support his leader's policy he had no option but to resign.

"It is a very difficult decision for me," he said. "I have always been a very loyal party man."

Asked if he was going to challenge for the leadership, Mr Abbott replied: "I am not going to talk about discussions I might have had with colleagues.

"I can’t say what might happen in the future but as far as I am concerned this is a policy issue not a leadership issue."

Mr Abbott said his office had had an "absolute deluge" of critical emails after Mr Turnbull announced the coalition’s support for the amended ETS.

"The phone lines have been in meltdown with people saying that the Liberal Party would not be doing its job as an opposition simply to pass this thing without scrutiny ... it demands," he said.

Liberal frontbencher Sophie Mirabella told Sky News her resignation was not a decision she took lightly but felt she had no option but to resign because she could not vote for the ETS.

She said it was not a matter of leadership and she was prepared to demote herself to vote against the "fundamentally flawed" legislation.

Mr Abbott said it had been a "pretty heavy week" for the party.

"And for someone who has a record of loyalty to the party and to the leader that I’ve had, this has been an incredibly momentous decision."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Turnbull and his ego should go. The ETS will do nothing to stop climate change, even if it is man-made which is in serious doubt. I hope the Liberals have the courage to vote no to this insane scheme.
Posted by Arden, 27/11/2009 7:09:38 AM
CONGRATULATIONS to the DISSIDENT members of the Coalition - YOU have just lost the next Federal election, and probably at least another one after that. What is it you don't understand about winning political strategy ???
Posted by AJ, 27/11/2009 7:33:30 AM
Turnbull has finally got the fame he has yearned for - the man who destroyed the Liberal party!
Posted by tigerdicky, 27/11/2009 8:25:42 AM
Don't you just love all that "helpful" advice on what is best for conservative voters that greens and Labor voters like to dish up for us at times like these? You know the stuff, right out of those one handed interviews on ABC? As if we would heed their gratuitous urgings after displaying their true colours so many times before. The real message, the only message worth heeding, is melting down the parliamentary phone system at this very moment. Oh yes, and that crashing noise you might have heard was the sound of Rudd's electoral margin taking a dive as Labor voters finally cotton on to what is going down. Go-oorn Kevie, have crack at a double dissolution mate, I dare ya.
Posted by Ian Mott, 27/11/2009 8:47:11 AM
AJ, I presume you are more than happy to suffer the consequences of this ETS tax? Do you believe the dissenting members of the Liberal party should have fallen into line behind Turnbull just to avoid political damage? At least one political party has members prepared to show some reason and strength in their own convictions. If anything it will do them good in the long run. Surely there is someone in the federal Labor party who has to be questioning the policy of this ETS tax. Or are they all just swept up in the Rudd/Wong climate hysteria and prepared to follow like lemmings over the cliff.
Posted by farmerpete, 27/11/2009 8:48:08 AM
We have all been conned as we focus on the politics and squabbling and not the content and substance of the legislation. Wake up Australia, stop being sucked in and being distracted from the real game which is exactly what Kevin and Penny want. What is it that our parliament is about to legislate? From what I can tell we now have an ETS plan which is what we all supposedly wanted, the only problem still is that no one has a clue what the detail really is. Has anyone actually worked out that the biggest issue for the majority of Liberals that quit is timing, not delivering a plan to reduce carbon emissions? Stop focusing on the battle and let's put our focus on the war. I believe that we need to address much of our polluting ways but not by introducing a massive inflationary tax slug. Scrap this atrocious piece of legislation that no longer resembles anything it began as. Do not give Kevin, Penny and Malcolm the trophy they want to take to Copenhagen; this is all much more important than that.
Posted by Katandra, 27/11/2009 9:14:59 AM
AJ, remember that it only takes a few who are willing to go beyond blind doctrine to have an affect on the direction of a nation. It is only a few who are pushing to rush the ETS legislation followed by the blind. Australia isn't going to sink into the sea if ETS legislation is not past before Copenhagen, so it should be voted on after Copenhagen. At least we will be better able to have legislation attuned to Copenhagen. Seems to be that Prime Minister Rudd fancies himself as someone of importance on the world stage and is making noises accordingly. If CO gases are that serious, then shut down everything immediately - coal power, agriculture, oil industry. They are the only contributors from man. Of course this won't happen as that would lose to much in tax wouldn't it. Prime Mister Rudd and Opposition leader Turnball's, answer is to actually give tax relief and grants to the worst polluters - why? Or is it that CO2 isn't actually a problem? As to losing the next election - remember it was a dissident Labor faction that ousted the Drover's Dog (Bill Haydon) weeks before an election and won.
Posted by gordons, 27/11/2009 9:18:35 AM
If Bob Santamaria is really Tony Abbott’s political hero then maybe he should start a right wing anti climate change party with the dissident sceptics’ and let any number of right minded and progressive thinking young Liberals take on the task (unenviable now) of rebuilding the Liberal party that might have a crack at Government in a decade or so… Really and Truly.
Posted by really and truly, 27/11/2009 9:30:43 AM
The global financial crisis, bushfires out of control due to conservation policies and growing numbers out of work and homeless should tell us something is wrong with our current government, be it Labor or Liberal. I remain a man-made climate change sceptic when it comes to the methane madness. Thank God some of our politicians still have a conscience and stand up for the truth and freedom. The ETS has disastorous implications for our economy and the well being of our people except for those high up the food chain.
Posted by Common Cents, 27/11/2009 9:39:19 AM
Tony Abbott is a fundamentalist Christian who allows religious beliefs to determine how he votes. I support the seperaiton of church and state. This has nothing to do with the ETS, this is about politicians' egos. I only hope we do not have a double dissolution as smashing the Liberal party will lead to an even more inneffective opposition. 13 years in power and the Libs do not know how to be an effective opposition and the politics is all the worse for it.
Posted by the lorax, 27/11/2009 9:58:54 AM
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Resigned ... Tony Abbott
Resigned ... Tony Abbott
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
25 November, 2009
24 November, 2009
POLL
Q: How has the deregulation of export wheat marketing affected your farm's profits this harvest?

Increased profits
(22.1%)

Decreased profits
(56.2%)

No change
(21.7%)

Total Votes: 258
Poll Date: 23 November, 2009
BLOGS
11 November, 2009
19 November, 2009
SPECIAL FEATURES

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...