News 
 National Rural News 
 Dairy 
 General 
 How the law is slowly killing our food 

How the law is slowly killing our food

23 Oct, 2009 08:06 AM
AUSTRALIA'S laws against the use of raw, unpasteurised raw milk are, in the eyes of Slow Food founder Carlo Petrini, symbolic of much that is wrong with modern food systems.

Signor Petrini last week began his fourth visit to Australia in Western Australia, where, in common with the rest of the country, the use of raw, unpasteurised milk for any purpose except pet milk has been banned.

Through an interpreter, Signor Petrini related how for a lunch with the WA Minister for Agriculture, Terry Redman, he was carefully served three superb cheeses—all made from raw milk, and all French.

“Basically you are convinced that French bacteria are better than Australian ones. Stupiditá!”

“Pasteurising milk is like killing it. You can’t make different types of cheese. You can’t tell the difference in the cows, the pastures, the farming land. In pasteurised milk, the taste is standardised—it would be like pasteurising wine.”

It’s an apparently minor issue for the nation’s food supply, but in Signor Petrini’s view an important one for the health of farming and our relationship with food.

He said that in the US, when a campaign to allow cheesemakers to use raw milk was finally won, the number of artisan cheesemakers exploded because a point of difference could be established against the major cheese producers.

A similar story occurred with US beer brewing.

“When we started there were just two main beers. Now there are also 4000 microbreweries,” he said.

“This is the difference; this is the new economy. Against the massive and standardised economy of the food industry, we want local economies that stand for creativity.”

The Slow Food movement has been charged with being elitist, enabling little more than a cosy communion between a few specialist farmers and a cashed-up yuppie clientele. That’s not what Signor Petrini wants of the movement, and he vigorously rejects the charge.

He says he wants to give dignity back to “food culture”—and not the food culture of TV chefs and “recipes, recipes, recipes”.

Slow Food gave impetus to the opening of the first two farmers markets in the US 20 years ago. By the mid-1990s there were 400, and now there are about 12,000, all offering farmers an alternative outlet for their produce.

Outrage at McDonalds’s plans to build one of its fast food restaurants in the Piazza di Spagna in Rome, the heart of the capital of a nation of food lovers, impelled journalist Carlo Petrini to found the international Slow Food movement in 1989.

Slow Food is all about what Signor Petrini believes fast food is not. The movement encourages sustainable small-scale farming, local economies built on communities of farmers and consumers (or “co-producers”), an emphasis on food quality, provenance and taste, and extended convivial eating.

The Slow Food event Terra Madre, held in Italy every two years, gathers small farmers and their supporters from across the world to discuss the formation of “food communities”.

The last Terra Madre, held in 2008, attracted more than 4000 farmers, fishermen and artisan food producers among the 6300 delegates.

* Slow Food Australia is mounting a campaign to have raw milk used in cheesemaking. For more information visit the Slow Food website.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Agreed - I cannot drink pasteurised milk or eat pasteurised cheese because of the synthetic processes and cultures and have ended up in hospital. But raw milk and cheese are wonderful joy to have. It seems all our allergies and cancers took off with the invention of the refrigerator and the storage and artificial preserving of food!!
Posted by Paul, 23/10/2009 11:26:26 AM
Raw milk is one of the regular causes of food poisoning and its perceived health benefits have not been scientifically demonstrated. Because of the public demand despite this, Food Standards Australia New Zealand is currently developing a standard that may allow certain raw milk cheeses to be produced, where the process involved in the manufacture of those cheeses removes any organisms of concern.

The draft of this standard wil be available for public comment early December. It wil not allow raw milk itself because of the public health risks associated with it.

Posted by Steve, 23/10/2009 1:31:26 PM
With the quantum leap in food handling and processing hygiene over the last few decades, it is theoretically possible that some of these processes could be discontinued. However, the whole subject must be approached with extreme caution.

Just because people have forgotten about the diseases, viruses and parasites that these processes got rid of does not mean that they no longer exist.

Paul, there's a strong body of opinion now amongst some medical professionals that our allergies and perhaps cancers are being caused because we live in a world that's too hygienic and our immune system is not being properly challenged and developed at an early age.

Posted by Qlander, 23/10/2009 1:32:42 PM
I agree with both sides. Proceed with precautionary principle in mind. We must look carefully at all our poisoned additive ridden food without going back to the dark ages. Julie Eady's Additive Alert can help here. We must seriously look at our treatment of animals, our depleted soils and the push towards GM. Allergies and food poisoning admissions to hospitals have skyrocketed in the last 20 years. These are conveniently overlooked facts, not greenie constructs.
Posted by michelle, 24/10/2009 9:37:18 AM
Pasteurisation and homogenisation of milk turns a good food into one that introduces a multitude of health challenges for vast numbers of consumers. Consumers should be allowed to make their own choice as to the "risks", if any, of consuming raw milk.
Posted by ggwagga, 26/10/2009 6:23:58 AM
It is an interesting concept that everything should become artificial or treated in some way to be not natural. WHY? What was really wrong with the milk and food we consumed from Grandma's Coolgardie Safe as children in rural Victoria? When the milk became sour after a few days it was then given to the dog or cat and neither of them died from consuming sour milk. Maybe it is a case of people becoming too 'lazy' to care for natural fresh food properly, and so they have come to rely on the preservatives.
Posted by Mildy farmer, 26/10/2009 10:53:45 AM
Steve, how can raw milk be "one of the regular causes of food poisoning" if it cannot be sold anywhere? You seem to have some trouble distinguishing past and present tense. Yes, raw milk was a problem when cows were hand milked on properties without electric power, without abundant hot water and delivered to a roadside stand by a horse and sled to be picked up by an unrefrigerated truck. And such properties are now found where, exactly? Which planet do these regulators inhabit? We can sell alcohol that seriously impairs the brain development of 18 year olds, and we can sell tobacco that kills thousands each year at huge expense, but we can't sell raw milk because it used to cause occasional, entirely treatable, tummy aches back when Steele Rudd was a boy. Which part of improper exercise of power, ie, "according to rule without regard for the merits of the particular case", do these geese not understand?
Posted by Ian Mott, 26/10/2009 10:55:45 AM
Consumers are not allowed to ingest healthy products like real unadulterated milk but our govts foist unsafe, contaminating GM into our food supply and agriculture before full testing is independently evaluated. For farmers and consumers who still believe this is a greenie plot see below:- Dr Henri Darmency, INRA, Dijon, France, is giving a lecture today re: Gene flow between canola and its wild relatives. Genetically-modified herbicide-resistant varieties of canola offer the possibility to spontaneously transfer the herbicide resistance to weedy Brassiceae through sexual crosses, thus jeopardizing the transgene-based strategy of weed control. Through specific experiments to explore the successive steps of the interspecific hybridization and the establishment of the introgressants in mustard and wild radish populations, and their consequences. Farmers GM and Non GM should all be able to attend this seminar on Monday afternoon October 26th at 4pm in the agriculture lecture theatre UWA to find out more before the moratorium is called off. Then attend the rally at Parliament House on the 18th of November to voice your objections before it's too late.
Posted by michelle, 26/10/2009 12:04:38 PM
Better check your internet Ian because food poisoning from raw milk occurs regularly in countries that allow it in some way, such as "cow sharing" in the US where the hygiene standards in the suppliers are as good as in any commercial dairy. The Listeria, Campylobacter & Salmonella organisms are always about to some degree, hence the need for interventions, either by pasteurisation or part of the cheese making process, to destroy those organisms.
Posted by Steve, 26/10/2009 1:19:33 PM
Sadly the Slow Food movement has in places been hijacked by elitist gourmets, particularly here in WA, where the idea of 'real' food is ignored and the ethics behind the movement have been abandoned to allow 'cashed -up' folk to indulge in specialist feasting. Vindana Shiva is the patron of Slow Food and a huge advocate for seed saving, which is totally against GM crops which deny farmers the right to save seeds. This is one of the major issues in the Slow Food movement, but any talk of adopting a GM free position is avoided by local convivia here in WA. I think Petrini needs to take control of this movement and steer it back to its roots supporting biodiversity and sustainability, neither of which can be found with GM crops.
Posted by Hebe, 26/10/2009 2:26:01 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Outrage at McDonalds’s plans to build one of its fast food restaurants in the Piazza di Spagna in Rome, the heart of the capital of a nation of food lovers, impelled journalist Carlo Petrini to found the international Slow Food movement in 1989.
Outrage at McDonalds’s plans to build one of its fast food restaurants in the Piazza di Spagna in Rome, the heart of the capital of a nation of food lovers, impelled journalist Carlo Petrini to found the international Slow Food movement in 1989.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
21 October, 2009
19 October, 2009
20 October, 2009
POLL
Q: Who do you think is the best person to lead the Federal Liberal Party?

Malcolm Turnbull
(46.4%)

Julie Bishop
(5.7%)

Tony Abbott
(10.3%)

Joe Hockey
(23.6%)

Other
(14.1%)

Total Votes: 760
Poll Date: 18 October, 2009

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...