News 
 National Rural News 
 Livestock 
 News 
 Disaster on the high seas - live animal export ship sinks 

Disaster on the high seas - live animal export ship sinks

22 Dec, 2009 08:45 AM
A FORMER Australian-owned live export ship transporting Uruguayan livestock sank near Lebanon on Thursday – drowning almost 18,000 cattle and over 10,000 sheep.

The MS Danny F II - formerly owned by Elders to transport Australian sheep from Australia to the Middle East until deemed unfit five years ago - was on its way from Uruguay to Syria.

Animal rights groups including the RSPCA and Animals Australia this week renewed their pressure on the Federal Government to shut down live export on ethical grounds, criticising the trade for being a part of the “long line of disasters” and the alleged death of some 40,000 sheep each year.

However, LiveCorp chief executive Cameron Hall defended the Australian livestock export industry and questioned this figure, saying 99 per cent of Australian livestock arrived fit and healthy at their destination.

“Australia operates under very strict regulations and uses only the best vessels to export our livestock,” Mr Hall said this week.

Despite LiveCorp's rebuttal, the groups remained unmoved on their plight.

Melina Tensen, RSPCA farm animal’s scientific officer, said it was “laughable” to suggest export trade was safe for livestock.

“The terrible drowning of the 28,000 cattle and sheep on the Danny F II highlights the inherent dangers in transporting live animals over such long distances but the majority of deaths at sea are actually related to the stress of being transported,” she said.

Similarly, Animals Australia executive director Glenys Oogjes said the sinking of the Danny F II, and the subsequent death of livestock and humans, showed the live export industry could not claim to appease to high animal welfare standards.

"When something goes wrong, such as fire, ventilation breakdown or extremes of weather, thousands of lives are lost," she said in a statement.

Regulation of the Australian industry includes full and thorough implementation of international maritime standards for vessels.

More than half the 83 crew members are still missing.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Those poor animals. Better they drown I am guessing than be slaughtered in the ME by the cruellest of ways imaginable. The trade really must stop. Australian farmers must stop supporting this ghastly bloodsucking business which puts nothing back into the pountry and start supporting Australia, Australian slaughterhouses and Australian workers.
Posted by TRUTH, 21/12/2009 2:08:51 PM
That is so incredibly sad. I had no idea the extent of this business and now I want to do more research.
Posted by monc, 21/12/2009 2:46:56 PM
Yet again another disaster in the history of live export. Thousands of animals losing their lives in the sea all for profit and greed. Possibly the ship was overloaded,further there is always the risk of fire, ventilation breakdown, weather extremes and the ever present dangers of the sea. Enough is enough live export must be shut down now.
Posted by Kathleen, 21/12/2009 3:11:47 PM
Truth: The trade will stop when the domestic processors consistently outbid the live exporters in the market place. Then it will die a natural death. If you want jobs and economic growth, then don't throw the livestock producers to the wolves to achieve it. Livestock producers have as much right to a living as anyone else. There is no agenda of greed, there is no agenda of cruelty. A livestock producers disposable income is well below the Australian average.
Posted by Brindi, 21/12/2009 3:36:35 PM
This ship has nothing to do with Australia and hasn't several years. No point in letting the facts get in the way of a good story is there.
Posted by Qlander, 21/12/2009 5:36:24 PM
Those poor seamen as well truth but they are not part of your cause. Not calling for the end of people going on boats are you? How about stopping planes, they fall out of the sky all the time. Livestock also die in truck crashes, would you like the end of truckies. Some times shit just happens.
Posted by THE FARMER, 21/12/2009 6:00:18 PM
Grazing animals do not belong on the sea, or crammed together. The stress and suffering must be enormous. This tragedy for animals and humans alike must be the death knell for live exports. It is just unsustainable in animal welfare, pollution, employment and our reputation overseas as an environmentally and animal-welfare friendly nation! The treatment of animals in a humane way cannot be guaranteed overseas. These animals may be the lucky ones!
Posted by Vivienne, 22/12/2009 8:20:21 AM
It is a tragedy, however when ships sink or planes crash the outcome is not to ban travel on them. Livecorp has done a magnificent job with improving conditions and lowering mortality rates on livestock shipping. We are now at the stage where mortality rates are comparable if not lower than on farm mortality. Livestock arrive in excellent condition well prepared for feedlots putting on condition to feed a hungry world.
Posted by Brad Bellnger, 22/12/2009 8:40:35 AM
The Farmer, I think the counter argument comes down to one word 'choice'. Humans as the, meant to be, highest order of intelligent life make the choice to do or not to do something that impacts on their life and the lives of all others we share this planet with. A big responsibility don't you think?
Posted by Marc, 22/12/2009 8:46:54 AM
Talk about drawing a long bow you stupid activist ( or was that just stupid people lol )!! Seems with that conclusion we should blame the car dealer for selling us cars we kill ourselves with or drink drive in!!!. Keep going with you stupid rubbish and before long no one will listen or fund you and its time we withdrew any government funding from such obsolete groups whos only goal in life is to see themselevs in print and have no clue as to the real world. Oh yes blame an Australian for something we no longer own lol . Oh yes talk about lunatics and fools . Psst I agree lets stop people flying of getting on boats or in cars we may get hurt LOL.
Posted by davo, 22/12/2009 9:10:09 AM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
17 December, 2009
18 December, 2009
21 December, 2009
POLL
Q: What will be the centre piece of your Christmas feast?

Beef
(9.4%)

Lamb
(8%)

Ham
(26.2%)

Turkey
(20.8%)

Seafood
(18.1%)

Vegetarian
(7.8%)

Other
(9.6%)

Total Votes: 562
Poll Date: 18 December, 2009

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC FW



Stock & Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...