News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Vegie farmers lash supermarkets 

Vegie farmers lash supermarkets

12/08/2008 11:32:00 AM
Sydney Basin farmer Mario Muscat prefers to sell his crops of cabbage, cauliflower and corn to small shops because he says the big supermarket chains are ripping off farmers.

He said Hawkesbury area farmers have seen the games played by the buyers for the supermarkets and they are sending farmers broke.

"For what the consumer has to pay, and what the farmer gets, the consumer's getting ripped off," Mr Muscat said.

His remarks are in response to the six-month inquiry into grocery prices by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission which found no evidence of anti-competitive behaviour by the supermarket chains towards fresh-produce suppliers.

Yet fruit and vegetable growers insist they are struggling to get fair prices from the big supermarkets and barely cover transport and packaging costs.

Former Hawkesbury citrus grower Bill McMahon, now a Flemington Markets grower representative, said he did not think the supermarkets paid well enough.

"Often stuff is returned to the grower on the pretext of quality but sometimes the supermarkets have overbought and just don't want to carry it," he said.

"They quote a price and renege on it [citing] quality."

Hawkesbury-Lower Nepean Water Users' Association chairman Paul Rasmussen, a Hawkesbury councillor, acts for more than 650 growers.

"Farmers are getting screwed," he said.

"The buyers, who act on behalf of the big boys, play games with the producers.

"They might say they don't want cabbages or cucumbers this week. So what do the farmers do?

"They have to take them all back.

"So the buyers say, 'We'll take them but we'll only give you half the normal price'."

Cr Rasmussen recommended that consumers support local farmers by shopping at their suburban greengrocers.

"Ask if it's grown locally," he said.

"There is already a trend to grow local and buy local."

A spokesman for Coles said: "We note that the ACCC has released the results of its inquiry which has stated that the supermarkets are paying fair prices for their produce and there is no evidence of exploitation by retailers."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
A spokesman for Coles said: "We note that the ACCC has released the results of its inquiry which has stated that the supermarkets are paying fair prices for their produce and there is no evidence of exploitation by retailers."

So are Mario Muscat and Paul Rasmussen being called liars by the Coles spoksman? Why did the ACCC only do half a job? There is positive proof that there is a definite policy of screwing the farmers by the big duopoly. Why isn't the ACCC listening? Are there other motives involved?

Posted by Trugger on 12/08/2008 9:15:56 PM
This is the level playing field Keating said we had to have and what the the big supermarket chains love to play on - sloped in their favour!
Posted by Tigerdicky on 13/08/2008 9:47:14 AM
It, not only in the fruit/vegetable markets that growers are being denied a fair and just price for their produce by the Coles Woolworth duopoly.

Read last Saturday's comments in the sydney morning herald by Vince Heffernan. Beef/lamb producers also have the same issue. Compare the price the producer receives with the price the consumer pays.

The producers of food in this country need to form a marketing alliance and create outlets for their produce. This would ensure a fair price for the producer and an alternative for the buying public which would deliver a value for money deal.

An initial meeting of interested producers could initiate a planning forum and develop strategy. Together producers could form a formidable presence in the marketplace. Comments please

Posted by maxi on 13/08/2008 11:40:57 AM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Tough times: VEGETABLE farmer Mario Muscat said the buyers for supermarket chains play games with farmers. Picture: Natalie Spiteri
Tough times: VEGETABLE farmer Mario Muscat said the buyers for supermarket chains play games with farmers. Picture: Natalie Spiteri
26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
NSW Beef Spectacular
 
Beef Week
 
Rural Bookshop
 
FSA online
 
Land Subscriptions
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
FET
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...